Loading polishes
The Index, in your pocketFavorites, boards, and your collection, synced with your phone →
The Index, in your pocketFavorites, boards, and your collection, synced with your phone →
Loading polishes
Images sourced directly from the Essie website at essie.com for accuracy. We never source images from third party sites.
No reviews yet for this shade. Be the first.
The nearest shades to Pencil Me In across other brands in the Index, ranked by color distance. Not sponsored, not guessed: measured from each polish's recorded color.
Keep exploring
Take the Index with you
Your Favorites, Inspo Boards, and Collection sync straight to the Polish Index app. Join the community, keep inspo at your fingertips, and unlock Pro perks like the Manicure (and Pedi) Tracker, a personal Allergen Profile, and so much more.
Scan or tap to download
Pencil Me In by Essie is a mid-tone, vivid raspberry with a cream finish.
Shop Essie's Pencil Me In from the Handmade With Love Collection. A salon-quality, vibrant magenta pink nail polish with blue undertones and cream finish.
In the Index, Pencil Me In is recorded as a mid-tone, vivid raspberry with a cream finish. That recorded color drives the swatch above and every match below.
Essie released it as part of the Original collection.
The shade that currently sits nearest to it in the Index is Kristie by Zoya. Every match below is ranked by color distance, not by name.
Regular
Ingredients --> Ingredients essie is a vegan brand – contains no animal-derived ingredients.
Create your personal Allergen Profile with Pro, in the Polish Index app: your avoid-list, flagged on every polish.
See ProEssie is not affiliated with or endorsed by Polish Index™.
Bio Sculpture
Royal Highness
98% match
Essie
Watermelon
